Book Review: Blood in the Water by Tiffany D Jackson
Blood in the Water marks an impressive middle-grade debut from Tiffany D. Jackson, delivering a sharp, suspenseful mystery filledwith social commentary and emotional depth. Read on for a spoiler-free book review of Tiffany D. Jackson’s Blood in the Water.
Set on Martha’s Vineyard, a place long known as a haven and cultural refuge for the African American community, the novel quickly makes it clear that beneath the sun-soaked beaches and charming façades, something far more unsettling is unfolding.
Kaylani McKinnon, a Brooklyn teen spending the summer with family friends, immediately feels out of place among the island’s polished homes and status-conscious teens. While the setting offers beach days, ice cream, and rich Black history, the social dynamics feel tight and performative. Jackson uses Kaylani’s outsider perspective to great effect, giving her a clear-eyed view into the classism, prejudice, and rivalries simmering just below the surface. When one teen turns up dead, the shock ripples through the community. The idea that one of their own could be responsible fractures trust and exposes long-standing tensions.
As an outsider, Kaylani becomes the perfect person to ask questions others are afraid to raise. She sees through the fake friendliness and social maneuvering, picking up on details that locals dismiss or deliberately ignore. Jackson fully immerses readers in the Martha’s Vineyard community, making the setting feel alive and deeply connected to the mystery itself. The island isn’t just a backdrop; it’s an active character in the story, shaping behavior, secrets, and silence.
Blood in the Water also explores how fear changes people. As suspicion grows, friendships strain and loyalty becomes conditional. Jackson thoughtfully examines how class and social standing influence who is protected and who is doubted, themes that are presented with clarity and care for a middle-grade audience. The book has a steady, creeping unease as Kaylani navigates shifting alliances and lies, keeping readers constantly questioning motives and appearances.
Kaylani is a fully realized, relatable character. Her fish-out-of-water experience gives her a rare view of the tension that ultimately leads to tragedy. Jackson’s pacing balances character development with mounting suspense, ensuring the emotional stakes are just as compelling as the mystery itself.
Blood in the Water is a book that is engaging, thoughtful, and quietly chilling. Tiffany D. Jackson proves her storytelling translates seamlessly to middle grade, offering a mystery that doesn’t shy away from hard truths while remaining accessible and gripping. This is a standout debut that lingers long after the final page, reminding readers that even the most beautiful places can hide something sinister underneath.
Other Scholastic Book Reviews:
Scholastic’s X-Men Coloring Book Review
Graphic Novel Review: Winging It
