Fanatical : The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara Shows the Downsides of Fame

Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara is a deeply compelling documentary that sheds light on the disturbing side of celebrity fandom, specifically through the lens of Tegan and Sara, two beloved indie-pop musicians. What starts as a heartwarming story about two artists who once thrived on connecting with their fans quickly becomes an unsettling narrative of betrayal and invasion of privacy. Read on for a review of the HULU documentary Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara, directed by Erin Carr.

The documentary recounts how Tegan and Sara’s early days of stardom were marked by genuine and open interactions with fans. Tegan, in particular, would help at merchandise tables and chat with supporters outside their tour bus. This accessibility built a strong bond with their fanbase, one that felt personal and authentic. However, as the duo’s fame grew, the need for more structured interactions, like VIP meet-and-greets, became necessary. This allowed Tegan and Sara to control who had access to them, but it was far from foolproof.

Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara delves into the shocking breach of privacy that occurred when Tegan’s iDisk and email were hacked, leading to the theft of personal information. What makes this documentary stand out is not just the fact that such an invasion happened, but the ripple effect it had on both the musicians and their fans. The hacker used this information to catfish unsuspecting fans, creating false online romantic relationships in Tegan’s name. Once the truth came out, fans would reach out to Tegan’s management, devastated after being manipulated by the hacker posing as the musician.

Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara explores the emotional toll of this ordeal on Tegan. As Tegan candidly shares feelings of sadness, anger, and distrust, you feel the weight of Tegan’s helplessness. Fanatical is a documentary that takes a raw look at how the very connections that once fueled Tegan’s passion for music turned toxic, leaving Tegan unsure of who to trust.

One of the most poignant moments in Fanatical, is when Tegan reconnects with JT, a former friend who was also catfished by the hacker. Their conversation is a raw and emotional exchange, full of shared pain and anger. Both express their humiliation at being deceived, but in a cathartic moment, they embrace, finding common ground in their mutual hurt. This scene isn’t easy to watch but life is uncomfortable and it really dives into the personal devastation wrought by the hacker, not just on Teagan’s professional life, but on her personal relationships as well.

The HULU documentary closes with a creepy update: one of Tegan’s hackers was traced to the UK, and over 2,000 emails were sent to fans by the “Fake Tegan.” Multiple hackers are still out there. It’s a sobering reminder of how fragile privacy can be, even for those who try to balance fame with personal connection to their beloved fans.

Fanatical is not just a story of cybercrime or even a whodunit mystery; it’s a cautionary tale about the complexities of fandom and the dark side of online relationships. Tegan and Sara’s journey through this nightmare serves as a reminder that the boundaries between fans and celebrities are delicate, and when crossed, the damage can be enormous.

Other HULU Documentaries

Documentary Review: Jacinta Is A Harrowing Tale of Multigenerational Trauma and Addiction in Maine

The Space Race: A Documentary Examining the Black History Side of the Race to Space